Skip to main content

New Best Way to Handle Dog Poop

I've found an even better way to dispose of dog poop than the one I documented in 2008 at http://ecopractice.blogspot.com/2008/03/best-way-to-dispose-of-dog-poop.html

It works by using a funnel-like attachment on your sewer cleanout so you can drop the dog poop directly into your sewer line without necessarily using any water!

Here is a picture of me doing this:




This is neater and easier than putting the dog poop in a toilet to flush. Saves water too.

The sewer cleanout accessory we use is the Doggie Doo Drain Dog Waste Sewer Line Attachment.

The reusable device we now use to pick up poop on walks (instead of using a plastic bag) is Nature's Miracle Jaw Scoop. It is easy to carry and holds the poop in the little bucket its jaws create. The medium size model can hold dozens of small poops or a couple of big poops from a big dog (we have little dogs). There is also a jumbo size if you need it.

If the poop is solid and not sticky, no water is needed as the poop just rolls down into the sewer. The poop in the sewer line gets flushed when water inside the house enters the sewer line. If the poop is sticky, using a little water from a nearby hose can rinse it down the funnel as well as rinse off the pooper scooper. Still less water used than a toilet flush.

The sewer system is the best way to handle both dog poop and human poop. I confirmed this with Sunnyvale waste management (both solid waste and sewage departments) as well as numerous online sources. Having trash sorters run into poop in the trash is not so pleasant (all trash in Sunnyvale is sorted to try to reclaim recyclables residents mistakenly put in the trash). Please note that cat poop is more problematic (toxoplasmosis survives sewage treatment and is fatal to sea otters in San Francisco Bay).

Note that our sewer cleanout is located in a great spot near our house so it is very convenient to use for dog waste disposal plus we can "smell" our sewer backing up outside before it backs up inside. This location of cleanout allows blockages to be more easily removed between our house and the street. Sewer cleanouts near the street probably won't work as well for either this dog poop disposal method or to allow the sewer line between your house and the street to be cleared easily.

Here are some closer pictures of our sewer cleanout. The funnel was a snap to install. It screws into the same threads that the black inner cap uses.












Here is a picture of the pooper scooper we use on walks (we normally keep it outside in the flowerbed next to our front door ready for the next walk):


Here is the one we use for our backyard (it stays outside in the back):



Waste reduction summary:
  1. Matter (material):
    1. No disposable flushing bags or plastic bags needed. Just reusable scoopers and funnel.
  2. Energy
    1. Less than needed to create, ship, buy, and dispose of poop bags. Just the one time manufacturing and shipping to get this reusable equipment. Piggybacks on existing sewer system with negligible additional energy (or water) needed.
  3. Time
    1. Picking up poop with scoopers is faster and easier than using a bag. Do need to remember to grab a pooper scooper when going for a walk.
  4. Space
    1. A little outside space occupied by reusable equipment, but less inside space that was previously occupied by empty poop bags.
  5. Money
    1. Cost is much less than buying bags (for us with 3 dogs that is 6 poops/bags a day or 2190/year at a cost of 2 cents per bag or $44 per year or $440 over 10 years. One time investment of about $50-60 for funnel and a scooper. (We used to use "free" bags from our newspaper and produce -- but since we no longer get a physical newspaper and use reusable bags for produce, we no longer have a "free" source.)
  6. Environment/Health/Life
    1. Disposing of poop this way is much healthier, safer, and better for the environment than having it go thru sorting and then entombing in a landfill. We will run out of landfills. Also eliminating the disposable plastic is extremely important as plastic from bags lasts hundreds of years and eventually poisons our creeks, rivers, oceans, and us. Sewer and septic systems are much more effective and efficient at handling human and dog waste than other methods.





Comments

guava said…
Tim, Thanks for documenting so clearly, and for letting us visit your home to see it in real life. We have made the leap and now have the poop claw and poop toilet installed. It works great. I am now bag-free, which was my goal. On top of that, no more smelly garbage in our garbage can. Thanks for your leadership.
jennrod12 said…
Tim, I got the attachment for putting dog poo in via the sewer cleanout for Christmas in 2021 and it has been fantastic! Thank you so much for this blog post that let me know about it.

I still pick up the poo with a plastic-ish bag, but I am able to use the same bag multiple times (I store the used bag outside). Another benefit I hadn't thought of is that now our garbage can doesn't stink! Therefore, we don't have to put it out every week, since there usually isn't much in it.

Popular posts from this blog

The best way to dispose of dog poop

Based on my research, the best way to handle dog poop is to use a reusable pooper scooper and flush the poop down a toilet . Pros: - Sewer systems are designed to handle poop (yours and your pet's) safely and effectively (this was verified by calling the local sewage treatment plant in Sunnyvale, California) - The poop is treated and recycled fairly quickly and safely back into the environment Cons: - Need to carry the poop to a toilet - Need to purchase or make a reusable pooper scooper Here are other alternatives generally listed from healthiest for environment to least healthy. Use a flushable poop bag and flush down a toilet. Pros: - Sewer systems are designed to handle poop - The poop is treated and recycled - Easy to carry bag around to pick up poop Cons: - Flushable bags can "melt" in rain or other very wet conditions - Flushable bags should be kept sealed in another plastic bag before use - Flushable bags are a bit expensive and hard to find - Flushable bags smell

No More Disposable Plastic!

Unfortunately the future is plastic because plastic lives just about forever and will be the death of much of our environment, and maybe us. If you have not already, please see Wall-E  for what our earth may eventually look like. We must do as much as possible to greatly reduce the use of plastic! Here is a seagoing bird that died from ingestion of plastic in the middle of the Pacific: From:  http://ecowatch.com/2013/05/28/california-plastic-pollution-policy-tangled-up-committee/ See also  http://www.nrdc.org/oceans/plastic-ocean/ and many other sources you can find by googling. And read the fantastic book  Plastic-Free: How I Kicked the Plastic Habit and How You Can Too . So my household is eliminating our need for plastic bags and other disposable plastic. No more hard copy newspaper with its plastic bag (see my separate post about my newspaper ). No more disposable plastic grocery bags (thank you for the local plastic bag ban -- now we must make sure it becomes